The importance of science in policy instruments application for land use
Brazil is a global agricultural heavyweight. The country is the world’s largest beef exporter and second largest beef producer. For soy it is both, largest producer and exporter. On the other hand Brazil hosts the largest remaining parts of the Amazon rain forests, as well as biodiversity hotspots and ecosystems of global importance. Experience with a decoupling of soy production and deforestation have shown that increasing welfare based on agricultural production does not necessarily need to be on the expense of natural resources. Decreasing deforestation rates in the early 2000’s has shown that political will can yield the desired effects. These are experiences that current policy making needs to build on. On the other hand, the sheer extend of irreversibly lost forest areas and the speed of ongoing deforestation raises concerns about the possibilities of national and international efforts for sustainable land use.
Our research shows that the Brazilian policy arrangement in the land use sector is complex but includes comprehensive legislation that probably provides all the tools needed for sustainable land use development on national level – if well implemented. There are policy strategies that cover all relevant sectors. They have evolved over time and reflect demands of various stakeholder groups. They reflect societal, economic and ecological challenges throughout the decades from an early focus on land settlement, to resource utilization, biodiversity conservation, restoration and climate change mitigation and adaptation in recent years.
Policy dialogue is needed to create a mutual understanding of this policy arrangement with its complex interrelations, links and dependencies and stakeholder groups benefitting and supporting specific policy instruments in many cases. Because a focus on single policy instruments, as often triggered by the international or European community will not be effective. Just increasing the extend of protected areas without taking into consideration needs of indigenous peoples or the national bioeconomy will not be successful.
Another example is the European deforestation free commodities regulation (EUDR) with its focus on traceability and a due diligence system to ban imports of “deforestation commodities”. Its successful implementation will depend on links with additional policy instruments like a functioning land registry (CAR), effective monitoring systems, information campaigns and capacity building specifically for smallholders, as well as enforcement measures. Support and cooperation measures need to take into account at least those policy instruments that have a direct and causal link to the EUDR. This will increase the effectiveness on one hand but as well ownership on the Brazilian side because then original Brazilian policy instruments are supported and considered in addition to an instrument that has rightly been blamed for its unilateralism.
Science can help to disentangle the network of policies and interests from an independent and rational perspective and by this play a role in the policy dialogue. It is also needed to check on the effectiveness of the different instruments and thus keep the attention wide to avoid a strong focus on only a single instrument as can currently be observed.
Autor


Die jüngsten Erfahrungen Brasiliens bei der Formulierung und Umsetzung politischer Maßnahmen, die auf Ernährungssouveränität und -sicherheit (SSAN¹
Dieser Artikel von Albano Araújo gibt einen Einblick in die wirtschaftlichen Aspekte der Agrarökologie in Brasilien, wie z. B. Märkte für Produkten aus der agrarökologischen und biologischen Erzeugung im Land, die finanzielle Tragfähigkeit der Produktion und die verfügbaren Finanzierungsquellen.

Weniger als sechs Monate bevor die EU-Entwaldungsverordnung (EUDR) in Kraft tritt, welche 2025 die Einfuhr von Agrarprodukten, die mit der Entwaldung in Zusammenhang stehen, verbietet, gibt es noch eine Reihe von Unsicherheiten.
Die EU-Entwaldungsverordnung (EUDR) zielt darauf ab, die nachteiligen Auswirkungen von EU-Importen auf die globalen Wälder, den Klimawandel und die biologische Vielfalt ab dem 31. Dezember 2024 zu verringern. Sie schreibt eine Sorgfaltsprüfung für Produkte vor, die waldgefährdete Rohstoffe wie Rindfleisch, Kakao, Kaffee, Ölpalmen, Kautschuk, Soja und Holz enthalten, um sicherzustellen, dass sie nicht von kürzlich abgeholzten Flächen stammen.
Die Landwirtschaft spielt eine zentrale Rolle bei der Förderung von Maßnahmen, die zur Verringerung und Beseitigung von Treibhausgasemissionen (Mitigation) und zur Anpassung an den Klimawandel führen, mit dem Ziel, die globale Ernährungssicherheit zu gewährleisten und zu den Klimazielen des Pariser Abkommens beizutragen.
Dieses Dokument bietet einen Überblick über die Agrarökologie in Brasilien, von ihren historischen und konzeptionellen Grundlagen bis hin zu den neuesten Techniken und Technologien.
